15 49.0138 8.38624 arrow 1 bullet 1 6000 1 0 fade https://blog.thepoolfactory.com 300 4000 1
America's Above Ground Pool Experts
Generic filters
Exact matches only

Pool Frog Mineral System vs. Salt Chlorine Generators

Compare the Pool Frog Mineral System versus Salt Chlorine Generators in this in-depth look by our above ground pool experts at The Pool Factory.
Print Friendly, PDF & Email

When you are deciding how you are going to sanitize your pool you may notice you have a few options.  The most common way people sanitize their above ground pool is with chlorine, either granular (powder) or tablets.

However, there are some alternative sanitizing systems that are also available. While they may still be using chlorine to clean the pool, it is in different forms and amounts. Two of the most common are mineral systems and saltwater systems, such as:

  1. Frog Pool Tender Fresh Mineral Water System
  2. Salt Chlorine Generator (ex. Solaxx Saltron Retro XL)
Frog Pool Tender Fresh Mineral Water System Package

The Frog Pool Tender system delivers a unique bacteria-killing combination: sanitizing minerals plus a very low level of chlorine. The result is Fresh Mineral Water∞ that gives you Cleaner, Clearer, Softer and Easier® water to maintain. Using fresh minerals means you use way less chlorine. Chambers are prefilled so there’s no mess, no guess, no stress.

Solaxx Saltron Retro XL

This self-contained purification system utilizes a natural process to generate pure chlorine. The electrolytic process uses a very low concentration of salt (less then a teaspoon per gallon) and generates free chlorine.

Mineral systems can be used on any pool model while a salt generator can ONLY be used with saltwater above ground pools like the Saltwater 5000 and the Saltwater 8000.

Pool Frog Mineral System vs. Salt Chlorine Generators

ComparisonsPool Frog Mineral SystemSalt Chlorine GeneratorWhy Minerals Are A Better Choice Than Salt
Uses chlorine to sanitize pool water.XXMinerals use 50% less chlorine. Salt chlorine generators are 100% chlorine!
Creates soft, clear water that’s easier on the eyes and skin.
XXMinerals improve water quality by reducing harsh chlorine. Salt chlorine generators do it by producing pure chlorine.
Eliminates storage of big chlorine buckets.XXMinerals use light weight pre-filled chlorine pacs for no mess. Salt chlorine generators manufacture chlorine on site.
Less work to maintain the pool.XMinerals are set-it-and-forget-it for weeks at a time. Salt chlorine generators require regular pH and chlorine monitoring.
Eliminates extreme chemistry conditions.XMinerals reduce chlorine to 0.5ppm. Chlorine levels at the salt chlorine generator cell can be as high as 50ppm^.
No sticker shock when replacing components.XMinerals cost about $100 per season while salt chlorine generator cells can cost up to 3-4x more.
No potential for rapid corrosion.XMinerals do not stain or corrode. Salt chlorine generator pools experience corrosion of stone work and metal parts including pool frame.
Eliminates warranty concerns on steel walled pools.XMineral Cyclers have a 10 year warranty. Many above ground manufacturers void their warranty if a salt chlorine generator is used.
pH stays in range with less monitoring.XMinerals absorb acids to keep pH in line. Salt chlorine generators constantly raise pH.
No regular cleaning to ensure performance.XMineral Cyclers have nothing to clean. Salt chlorine generators cells must be cleaned with acid regularly.
Saves money annually with no electricity costs.XMineral Systems use no electricity so they save money over salt chlorine generators.

About The Pool Factory

America’s Above Ground Pool Experts – is the best place to find everything you need to make owning a swimming pool or spa fun and easy, at the best prices today. With a combined 50+ years of experience The Pool Factory employs a highly trained staff of above ground and semi inground pool specialists. The Pool Factory can provide unique solutions for all pool supplies and swimming pool needs.

  • July 21, 2015 at 5:01 PM
    steve fountain

    I have an old Pool Frog system and I think the flow switch needs replacing. Do they still make those switches or is there a substitute?

    • July 24, 2015 at 11:55 AM

      Hi Steve,

      Do you have an inground or above ground system? Are you referring to the the control dial assembly?

Shop at The Pool Factory